How to Reproduce Published Paper Regression Tables and Figures from Open Data
Open-data replications frequently diverge from published tables on sample sizes, point estimates, or standard errors. Here is how to diagnose and resolve discrepancies systematically.
HumanPen Team
· 11 min read
Direct answer: reproducing regression tables and figures from open data
Reproducing published regression tables and figures from open data rarely matches on the first run due to unrecorded pipeline choices. Sample size differences usually stem from filtering order, dropped singleton fixed effects, or missing-value handling. Discrepant standard errors typically reflect clustering degree-of-freedom adjustments or sandwich estimator defaults across software. A systematic audit requires verifying summary statistics first, logging observation drops sequentially, aligning clustering formulas, and locking the baseline before testing extensions.
Methodological checkpoint: A replication divergence does not automatically mean the original authors falsified findings or that your code is broken. Most numerical differences arise from undocumented data-filtering sequences, automatic dropping of singleton fixed effects in panel models, or subtle variations in standard-error clustering degrees of freedom between econometric software packages.
Graduate students and empirical researchers routinely encounter these obstacles when downloading replication archives from Zenodo, Harvard Dataverse, or ICPSR. When scripts fail to replicate published tables immediately, researchers often suspect file corruption or hidden errors. In practice, data pipelines contain unstated conventions—such as how missing values are filtered or how multidimensional fixed effects drop isolated groups. Before adjusting estimation equations as described in our safe methods and results revision checklist, or auditing underlying literature via our citation verification and DOI audit guide, you must establish computational equivalence with the published baseline.
Six technical causes of replication discrepancies in open research data
When executing an author's raw script against open data, numerical divergences cluster around six specific technical mechanisms. Understanding these causes allows researchers to diagnose whether a discrepancy originates in data transformation, sample definition, or variance estimation.
| Discrepancy Source | Technical Mechanism | Typical Diagnostic Signature | Verification and Audit Fix |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sample-Drop Order | Filtering steps executed in a different sequence than documented in prose | Total sample size `N` differs by dozens to hundreds of observations | Print intermediate `N` after every filter condition and align with codebook |
| Fixed-Effect Singletons | Multi-way fixed-effect algorithms dropping groups with only one observation | `N` is slightly smaller in panel models than in pooled OLS models | Check `drop_singletons` parameter across Stata, R, and Python packages |
| Standard-Error Clustering | Differences in small-sample finite cluster degree-of-freedom scaling | Point estimates match exactly, but standard errors differ by `1%` to `3%` | Specify explicit finite-sample degrees-of-freedom multipliers `(G/(G-1))` |
| Sampling & Analytic Weights | Ambiguity between frequency weights, probability weights, and analytic weights | Point estimates drift across all covariates while unweighted `N` matches | Confirm whether the original model applied survey probability weights |
| Package & Solver Versions | Optimization tolerance defaults and numerical convergence solver changes | Point estimates match in early digits but diverge beyond three decimals | Pin exact package releases and convergence thresholds `tol = 1e-8` |
| Stochastic Random Seeds | Unseeded bootstrap replications, cross-validation splits, or synthetic controls | Re-running the exact same script produces slightly fluctuating estimates | Add explicit `set.seed(...)` statements and evaluate sampling distribution |
A frequent source of hidden sample attrition is the interaction between data cleaning and high-dimensional fixed effects. Modern panel estimation routines—such as `reghdfe` in Stata, `fixest::feols` in R, or `linearmodels` in Python—absorb high-dimensional fixed effects iteratively. When a cluster group contains only a single observation (a singleton), retaining that observation can artificially distort standard errors without contributing within-group identification variance. Consequently, modern absorbed algorithms drop singletons by default. However, if the original authors ran an older routine or included explicit dummy variables in standard OLS, singletons were retained, producing an apparent mismatch of 20 to 50 observations when replicated with modern tools.
Numerical precision alert: When auditing regression tables, evaluate point estimates and standard errors as distinct diagnostic dimensions. If point estimates align perfectly while standard errors differ by a constant scaling factor (such as 1.012), your underlying sample and regression equations are completely sound, and the difference is purely an artifact of small-sample cluster degree-of-freedom formulas.
Constructing a side-by-side original versus replicated audit table
Rather than modifying scripts haphazardly when numbers diverge, researchers should record every discrepancy in a structured audit table. Tracking published metrics against replicated outputs across every specification isolates whether errors stem from data ingress, missing controls, or variance calculations.
| Table Column & Specification | Published Metric | Replicated Output | Absolute Difference | Diagnostic Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Model 1 OLS Baseline (Observations N) | `N = 14,250` | `N = 14,212` | `-38` | Singleton clusters dropped by absorbed estimator |
| Model 1 Treatment Effect (Point Estimate) | `0.0428` | `0.0428` | `0.0000` | Exact computational match on point estimate |
| Model 1 Clustered SE | `(0.0124)` | `(0.0121)` | `-0.0003` | Small-sample scaling factor `sqrt(G/(G-1))` missing |
| Model 2 High-Dimensional FE (Point Estimate) | `0.0381` | `0.0354` | `-0.0027` | Winsorization threshold discrepancy in raw covariates |
| Figure 4 Event-Study Lead -2 | `-0.0041` | `-0.0041` | `0.0000` | Exact alignment across tabular and plotted coordinates |
- Audit raw data ingress and summary statistics: Compute means, standard deviations, minimums, maximums, and missing-value counts for all variables in `data/raw_survey.csv` and verify against Table 1 before running regressions.
- Log observation attrition sequentially: Insert verification print statements logging the exact row count `N` after each filtering step to detect whether missing covariates or outlier rules were executed first.
- Harmonize software-specific estimation options: In R or Python, verify clustering options (such as setting explicit cluster variables and small-sample correction flags) to match Stata's `vce(cluster ...)` output.
- Inspect outlier treatment and variable transformations: Check whether continuous covariates were log-transformed as `log(x + 1)` versus `log(x)` or winsorized at the 1st and 99th percentiles before or after sample selection.
- Reconstruct figures from underlying numerical vectors: Export point estimates and confidence interval bounds to CSV before plotting, comparing numerical values against published vector charts.
Understanding reasonable tolerance thresholds prevents unnecessary troubleshooting. In empirical econometrics, point estimates should match published tables to the final reported decimal place. Minor standard error divergences below 0.0005, however, frequently arise from floating-point matrix operations or software degree-of-freedom conventions. Documenting these technical nuances in an audit note demonstrates rigorous scholarship to advisers and journal editors.
Extending the analysis with robustness checks after locking baseline replication
A cardinal rule of quantitative replication is that extensions must never precede baseline verification. If a researcher introduces alternate controls, changes clustering levels, or splits samples before matching published baseline numbers, any subsequent discrepancy cannot be interpreted with scientific validity.
| Extension Category | Analytical Purpose | False Divergence Risk | Methodological Protocol |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alternate Clustering Levels | Shifting cluster level from state to county, or two-way clustering | Underestimating standard errors if cluster counts are too small | Apply wild cluster bootstrap if clusters are fewer than 30–50 |
| Covariate Perturbations | Adding or dropping lagged covariates or sector fixed effects | Introducing bad controls or conditioning on post-treatment mediators | Pre-specify covariate sets using causal DAGs and compare against baseline |
| Subgroup Heterogeneity | Splitting samples by firm size, regional tier, or demographic subgroup | P-hacking across arbitrary cutoffs without formal interaction tests | Estimate pooled models with interaction terms rather than isolated splits |
| Alternative Functional Forms | Replacing linear probability models with logit or Poisson pseudo-maximum likelihood | Incomparable coefficient interpretations across nonlinear specifications | Compute average marginal effects to compare economic magnitudes directly |
Academic integrity boundary: When writing seminar papers, master's theses, or journal manuscripts based on open datasets from Harvard Dataverse or Zenodo, you must clearly separate the computational reproduction of the original author's findings from your independent extension work. Explicitly disclose data provenance and cite the original data deposit alongside the published article.
Following the reproducibility standards established by the Social Science Data Editors ensures that both baseline replications and subsequent extensions remain fully reproducible. Structure project directories logically (`code/`, `data/`, `deliverables/`), build a single master execution script (`run_all.py` or `master.R`) that regenerates all tables and figures from raw data without manual intervention, and document software dependencies to preserve research transparency.
Automated replication support with HumanPen Start Project
When researchers need to audit an open-data replication efficiently, HumanPen's dedicated replication workflow accelerates the process. Researchers can launch this on HumanPen Start Project. Attach your data and papers, describe what you need, approve the plan before work starts, and get the reviewed report, charts, and code ready to preview online or download. Whether you have a published paper PDF, an author's CSV from Harvard Dataverse, or a raw Zenodo replication bundle, the system structures the audit by mapping published figures to reproducible scripts.
Technical environment and data boundaries: HumanPen Start Project processes datasets and literature up to 2 GB in Excel, CSV, Word, PDF, or zip archives within an isolated sandbox. Statistical analyses originally written in SPSS or Stata are performed using Python or R; proprietary institutional databases like Wind or CNKI must be exported by the user before upload. Tasks are billed by actual resource usage, work is retained for 6 months with full on-demand deletion, and GPU training is not supported.
- Input upload and specification matching: Upload the published paper PDF, author's raw CSV datasets, and any original Stata or R scripts; specify the exact tables (such as Table 2) and figures (such as Figure 4) you need to replicate.
- Detailed implementation plan review: Before any computation begins, review the generated replication plan outlining data ingestion pipelines, proposed econometric packages, and discrepancy check metrics, confirming before work starts.
- Sandbox execution and discrepancy detection: The system runs data cleaning, identifies singleton drops, estimates baseline regressions in Python or R, and detects point estimate or standard error variances against published tables.
- Automated dual-stage review verification: Deliverables undergo a secondary validation check to verify that all script formulas, output tables, and graphical axes match the agreed scope without syntax failures or runtime errors.
- Delivery of reports, figures, and verified code: Receive a complete `.docx` discrepancy audit report, high-resolution vector figures, CSV numerical summary tables, and a standalone reproducible script ready to preview online or download as a zip archive.
To inspect real-world outputs from this architecture, researchers can examine verified public examples on HumanPen Start Project, such as the secondary analysis of the International Stroke Trial, where 19,435 randomized patients from a public dataset were audited to reproduce published clinical trial mortality endpoints and subgroup forest plots. As with all academic projects, deliverables serve as a methodological and educational reference draft: researchers and students must inspect all generated code, verify findings independently, and adhere to their university or journal AI policies.
Frequently asked questions about paper replication
What should I do if the replicated regression sample size N differs by only a dozen observations from the published paper? A minor sample discrepancy of 10 to 50 observations almost always indicates a difference in missing-value filtering or singleton fixed-effects handling rather than bad data. First, examine whether the original paper used Stata's `reghdfe` command, which automatically detects and drops singleton clusters that lack within-group variation. In R (`fixest::feols`) or Python (`linearmodels`), singletons may be retained unless explicitly dropped via parameters like `drop_singletons = TRUE`. Second, verify the sequential ordering of sample filters in your data preparation code: dropping records with missing control variables before applying age or sector filters often eliminates different observations than applying demographic filters first.
Why do R, Stata, and Python produce identical point estimates but slightly different standard errors for the exact same regression? When point estimates match to five decimal places but standard errors differ slightly, the discrepancy is caused by differing small-sample degrees-of-freedom corrections applied to the variance-covariance matrix. Stata's `vce(cluster ...)` option applies a finite-sample multiplier of `(G / (G - 1)) * ((N - 1) / (N - K))`, where `G` is the number of clusters, `N` is sample size, and `K` is the number of estimated parameters. In contrast, standard R robust packages or Python's `statsmodels` sandwich estimators may use `G / (G - 1)` without multiplying by `(N - 1) / (N - K)`, or may calculate `K` differently when absorbing fixed effects. Explicitly configuring the small-sample degrees-of-freedom adjustment flags across software packages resolves this gap.
How should I proceed if an author's replication package relies on outdated software packages or deprecated syntax? Older replication archives stored on Harvard Dataverse or Zenodo often rely on legacy package functions that fail to compile or throw syntax errors in modern R or Python environments. Instead of immediately rewriting the author's logic, create an isolated virtual environment (using tools like `renv` in R, `venv` or `conda` in Python) pinned to the release dates noted in the paper's documentation. If specific package versions are unstated in the repository README, inspect the publication date of the paper and install package binaries contemporaneous with that submission year. Once the baseline environment replicates published numbers, you can translate the logic into modern packages like `fixest` or `statsmodels` while benchmarking outputs against the verified legacy baseline.
Does achieving an exact numerical replication prove that the paper's scientific conclusions are robust and credible? No. Successfully reproducing identical regression tables and figures proves "computational reproducibility" (confirming that the author's code applied to the deposited data generates the published numbers), but it does not establish "empirical replicability" or scientific validity. Computational reproduction cannot detect whether the original sample was subject to unobserved selection bias, whether omitted variable confounding undermines causal identification, or whether key findings dissolve under alternative clustering levels or sample timeframes. Computational verification is the essential prerequisite for credible empirical scrutiny, providing the locked foundation required to conduct meaningful robustness tests, placebo checks, and policy evaluations.
Sources and primary references
The replication audit methodologies, diagnostic checks, and reproducible workflow standards in this guide are grounded in established scientific guidelines and data repository documentation:
- Institute for Replication (I4R) — Reproducibility & Replicability Standards — Methodological guidelines and systematic protocols for evaluating computational reproducibility, robustness checks, and empirical replications across the social sciences.
- Social Science Data Editors — Template README and Computational Reproducibility Checklist — Official reproducibility standards defining data provenance requirements, package version documentation, sequential pipeline execution, and code repository organization.
- Zenodo — Describing Deposit Records and Persistent Software/Data DOIs — Technical standards for archiving research data, open-source code packages, and persistent versioned Digital Object Identifiers.
KEEP READING