arXiv and bioRxiv Preprints in Journal Submissions: iThenticate Similarity Checks and AI Detection Rules

Depositing a manuscript on arXiv or bioRxiv does not disqualify your paper at major journals, but Crossref Similarity Check will flag high database overlap unless properly filtered; understanding how iThenticate 2.0 categorizes repositories, why text matching is separate from AI detection add-ons, and how to declare preprints ensures a smooth submission.

HumanPen Team

· 11 min read

Do Preprints Trigger Plagiarism or AI Flags in Journal Submissions?

Posting a preprint on arXiv, bioRxiv, or another repository does not disqualify your manuscript at major academic publishers, but it will appear in Crossref Similarity Check with an elevated similarity score—often 70% to 95%—unless properly recognized and excluded. While iThenticate 2.0 automatically flags preprints from 23 dedicated servers, repositories like SSRN, Zenodo, and OSF Preprints are not auto-labeled. Crucially, text matching against your preprint has zero impact on AI writing detection, which is an entirely separate paid add-on.

Major publishers including Springer Nature, Elsevier, IEEE, and Wiley explicitly allow preprint submissions. In iThenticate 2.0, text similarity to an author's own registered preprint is recognized as legitimate prior dissemination rather than plagiarism, provided it is transparently disclosed in your cover letter.

When an author receives an automated notice showing an 85% or 90% similarity score, panic is a common reaction. Researchers often assume their submission will face an immediate desk rejection or trigger automated academic misconduct inquiries. In reality, editorial triage relies on understanding three underlying operational rules: how iThenticate categorizes preprint servers into included, unincluded, and pending repositories; why algorithmic text matching has no connection to generative AI classifiers; and how transparent portal declarations prevent automated triage bottlenecks.

How iThenticate 2.0 Handles Preprints: Included vs. Unincluded Repositories

Crossref Similarity Check is built directly on the iThenticate 2.0 platform and shares its core matching engine, document databases, and interface features. To prevent manuscripts with preprints from generating misleading similarity flags, iThenticate analyzes harvested repository metadata and canonical source URLs to identify preprint documents. When a match is detected, the system applies the badge `Contains Preprint source`. Depending on administrative configuration set by the journal publisher, the system can be configured to `Label and exclude` preprints automatically, display the label while keeping the percentage intact, or ignore preprint filtering entirely.

Repository CategoryServer Examples & CoverageHow iThenticate 2.0 Evaluates ContentImpact on the Similarity Report
Included Repositories (23 dedicated preprint servers)arXiv, bioRxiv, medRxiv, ChemRxiv, TechRxiv, Research Square, EarthArXiv, SciELO Preprints, ChinaXiv, Cryptology ePrint Archive, Cambridge Open EngageHarvested metadata and URLs confirm the repository exclusively hosts preprints without peer-reviewed final articlesTagged with `Contains Preprint source`; automatically excluded from the similarity percentage if the journal activates preprint filtering
Unincluded Repositories (12 mixed or inaccessible platforms)SSRN, Preprints with The Lancet on SSRN, Zenodo, Preprints.org, NBER Working Papers, JMIR Preprints, Advance (SAGE), Cell Sneak PeekPlatform hosts mixed content (peer-reviewed papers, book chapters, datasets) or restricts crawler access, preventing reliable automated classificationNot labeled as preprints; treated as standard web or publication sources, requiring manual source exclusion by the handling editor
Identified But Unincluded (25 pending servers)OSF Preprints, PsyArXiv, SocArXiv, Authorea, EdArXiv, ESS Open Archive, LawArXiv, MetaArXivAcknowledged as dedicated preprint servers by Turnitin and iThenticate engineers but not yet integrated into automated metadata filtering rulesNot automatically tagged with preprint badges; matches appear as regular third-party repository text until manually reviewed

The rationale behind this division is technical rather than policy-driven. As iThenticate's official administrative documentation clarifies, repositories such as SSRN and Zenodo host a mixture of preprint working papers, post-peer-review author manuscripts, licensed conference proceedings, and institutional datasets. If iThenticate were to blanket-exclude every domain link from `ssrn.com` or `zenodo.org`, it would inadvertently mask genuine plagiarism from peer-reviewed articles indexed across those multi-purpose repositories. Consequently, iThenticate restricts automated exclusion strictly to the 23 dedicated preprint-only servers.

This technical limitation does not mean an author who posted to SSRN, Zenodo, or OSF Preprints will be penalized. In the enhanced Similarity Report interface, handling editors have access to the `Excluding a source` feature. When an editor reviews a report, opens the matched source list, and verifies that the 85% match stems from the author's own working paper on SSRN, the editor can click to exclude that specific source. The system immediately recalculates the similarity index across the remainder of the manuscript, removing the preprint match completely from the final score.

Why High Preprint Similarity Has Zero Effect on AI Writing Detection

A frequent concern among early-career researchers is that an 80% or 90% text match against an arXiv or bioRxiv draft will trigger Turnitin's AI writing detector or increase their AI probability score. This anxiety reflects a fundamental misunderstanding of academic screening tools. String-matching similarity reports and statistical AI writing detection operate on separate technological pipelines, evaluate completely different document features, and do not influence each other. To understand how editorial offices deploy these capabilities, see our detailed guide on whether academic journals check for AI writing.

Turnitin's AI writing detection is an optional, paid add-on within iThenticate 2.0. Having an extensive text match against a registered preprint in Crossref's text database neither raises nor lowers your AI writing percentage; the similarity engine and the AI detection model run independently.

The two engines analyze manuscript files through fundamentally distinct methods. The similarity engine extracts n-gram token sequences and searches against billions of web pages, publisher archives, and preprint repositories to locate identical or paraphrased phrases. By contrast, the AI writing detection model does not query external document databases at all. Instead, it evaluates the probabilistic structure of the submitted text—measuring sentence-level perplexity and burstiness to estimate whether word choices reflect the statistical uniformity typical of large language models.

  • Prose length requirements: Files must contain between 300 and 30,000 words of continuous prose text; manuscripts under 300 words do not generate an AI Writing Report or percentage score.
  • Language limitations: The AI detection model only processes seven supported languages: English, Spanish, Japanese, Arabic, Turkish, Dutch, and German.
  • Non-prose exclusions: The AI model evaluates prose sentences while automatically ignoring mathematical formulas, source code, data tables, and bulleted lists.
  • File constraints: Submissions are supported in `.docx`, `.pdf`, `.txt`, and `.rtf` formats, with an individual file size limit of 100 MB.

Furthermore, many academic journals using Crossref Similarity Check do not license or activate the optional AI writing add-on. For editorial boards that do license both tools, the outputs appear in separate interface panels: a traditional Similarity Score on one side and an AI indicator on the other. Editors are instructed to evaluate each metric under distinct guidelines. For an analysis of how editors interpret these split screens, review our breakdown on how to read iThenticate AI writing reports.

Publisher Preprint Policies: Springer Nature, Elsevier, IEEE, and Wiley

While iThenticate provides the technical detection interface, publishing ethics and editorial policies determine how editors act on similarity reports. Major scientific, technical, and medical publishers universally recognize preprints as legitimate forms of early scientific dissemination rather than prior publication. However, each publisher has distinct submission requirements, evolutionary referencing rules, and review-model exceptions that authors must navigate.

Publisher / AssociationPrior Publication PolicyStance on Similarity Checking & RepositoriesSubmission Requirements & Key Exceptions
Springer NaturePreprints are not considered prior publication and will not jeopardize consideration; preprints may be posted at any point during peer reviewRoutinely screens submissions with Crossref Similarity Check; guidelines advise editors that matches against an author's registered preprint are permittedRecommends explicitly declaring the registered preprint DOI and URL in the cover letter so the editor can verify it prior to screening
ElsevierElectronic preprints are an explicit exception to multiple or duplicate publication restrictions; authors may share preprints anywhere at any timeAccepts similarity matches to an author's preprint as legitimate pre-publication versionsWarns that certain society-owned journals and double-anonymized peer-review titles maintain independent, restrictive preprint rules
IEEEFully supports the evolutionary publication process (PSPB Operations Manual, June 2026, §8.1.7.F, §8.1.9) on personal, employer, and approved not-for-profit servers (TechRxiv, arXiv)Section 8.2.2.B mandates that editors who suspend review due to similarity must inform authors and provide an opportunity to explain before deciding plagiarismAuthors must fully reference the evolutionary publication history; upon formal publication, authors must update the preprint with the official IEEE DOI
WileyGeneral policy allows submission of manuscripts previously deposited on preprint servers; preprint availability is not a disqualifierScreens submissions routinely via Crossref Similarity Check; preprint duplication is acceptable when transparently disclosedIndividual Wiley journals set policies independently; requires transparent disclosure and explicit citation in the submitted manuscript

A critical trap involves submitting to journals operating under double-anonymized (double-blind) peer review. While single-anonymized journals allow authors to cite their preprints directly in the main text or acknowledgments, doing so in a double-blind manuscript will reveal author identity to peer reviewers. If you include phrases like "in our earlier preprint (Smith et al., 2025)" or link to an unblinded arXiv entry, the editorial office will reject the submission for formatting non-compliance. In double-blind submissions, disclose the preprint strictly in the confidential cover letter or portal metadata, cite the work neutrally in the third person if necessary, and check whether the journal permits preprint dissemination during review.

Authors should also pay close attention to society-owned journals. Even when published under the umbrella of large houses like Elsevier or Wiley, journals owned by specialized medical or engineering societies may retain independent editorial bylaws. For instance, clinical medicine journals occasionally restrict public preprints that announce preliminary patient outcomes before complete peer evaluation. Consulting the specific journal's `Guide for Authors` before submission ensures full alignment with individual editorial board rules.

Submission Checklist: How to Declare Preprints and Handle Editorial Triage

To ensure that an automated similarity check against your preprint never slows down manuscript processing, integrate the following four-step disclosure protocol into your submission workflow:

  • 1. Disclose the preprint in your cover letter: State clearly in your letter to the Editor-in-Chief that an earlier working draft is available on a public repository, specifying the platform name (such as arXiv, bioRxiv, or SSRN), the assigned DOI, and the direct web link.
  • 2. Complete repository fields in the submission portal: In manuscript tracking portals (such as Editorial Manager, ScholarOne, or Elsevier Editorial System), locate the specific disclosure prompt regarding preprints or repositories and enter your DOI and server details.
  • 3. Protect anonymity for double-blind submissions: When submitting to a double-anonymized journal, verify its preprint stance, avoid self-identifying citations or URLs inside the blinded manuscript file, and confine all preprint disclosures strictly to confidential cover letters or portal form fields.
  • 4. Maintain a rapid-response template for editorial office queries: If an editorial assistant sends an automated notification asking you to explain an 80% similarity score, reply immediately with a professional message identifying the match as your own preprint, citing the publisher's permissive preprint policy.

If an editorial assistant or associate editor contacts you regarding an elevated similarity report, remain calm and professional. A prompt response providing the title, author list, posting timestamp, and DOI of your preprint confirms that the match is legitimate scientific dissemination. Handling editors routinely resolve these inquiries in minutes by adjusting iThenticate's exclusion filters or manually excluding the repository source, allowing the manuscript to proceed directly to peer review.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does posting on arXiv or bioRxiv prevent me from submitting to high-impact journals like Nature, Science, or IEEE Transactions? No. Flagship journals published by Springer Nature, the American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS), IEEE, and Elsevier explicitly permit authors to submit manuscripts previously deposited on community preprint servers. These publishers consider preprints valuable mechanisms for establishing research priority, obtaining peer feedback, and accelerating open science rather than forms of competing prior publication.

What should I do if my preprint is on SSRN, Zenodo, or OSF Preprints and Crossref flags an 85% similarity score? Because SSRN, Zenodo, and OSF Preprints host mixed academic content or have restricted crawling parameters, iThenticate 2.0 does not automatically tag them with the preprint badge. If an automated triage notification flags this similarity, inform the editorial assistant in your reply that the match corresponds to your own preprint, providing the URL and author list. The editor will use the `Excluding a source` button in iThenticate to manually remove the repository from the similarity calculation.

Can Turnitin's AI writing detection add-on flag my preprint if the paper includes complex equations or code? No. Turnitin's AI writing detection add-on ignores non-prose elements including mathematical notation, LaTeX equations, computer code, data tables, and bullet points. More importantly, similarity matching against your preprint draft in Crossref's text database does not affect the AI writing detector, which evaluates statistical sentence structure rather than database text overlap.

Should I withdraw or delete my arXiv or bioRxiv preprint once my journal article is formally accepted? No. Preprints posted to arXiv, bioRxiv, or medRxiv receive permanent Digital Object Identifiers (DOIs) and form permanent records in the scientific literature that cannot be deleted. Standard publisher guidelines—including those from Elsevier, Springer Nature, and IEEE—advise authors to update their preprint repository records by adding a link and formal citation to the final published journal Version of Record (VOR).

Sources

The technical specifications, repository classifications, and publisher policies described in this guide are verified against official documentation and operating statutes as of 2026:

KEEP READING